This is what I want, but I know it is not what you or every guest wants. Airbnb itself is a new thing for many travelers -- we always have guests who identify as "first-timers' -- and some are nervous about what they will or will not find when they aren't booking a hotel.
Because all of our spaces are on Airbnb, I have many guests who express worries about booking for the first time. I've also had many conversations with friends and acquaintances who give me arched eyebrows or suspicious squints when I explain how Airbnb works. No matter what, I'm always happy to introduce guests to the community or give new exposure to Urban Roost. Still, I know that Airbnb is not for everyone. Urban Roost is not for everyone.
So let me be as honest as I can. Here are my tips for whether you should choose a hotel or an Airbnb.
You should choose a hotel if you....
- ...cannot live without cable TV or local news. While many Airbnbs do have cable (check the listing), most hosts -- like most consumers -- have started to opt out of high-priced cable or DirectTV services. If you need your dose of morning talk shows, local punditry, or the Weather Channel, best to go with what you know.
- ...aren't used to apartment living. If you book a stay in an apartment on Airbnb, chances are there will be other units in the building with other guests or tenants. Although hosts work hard to list quiet hours and ask for courtesy, they can't prevent your upstairs neighbors from arriving home at midnight in heels or dropping the tea kettle on the floor. If such an occurrence will destroy your night, then go with what you know.
- ...need a predictable continental breakfast. If you aren't interested in exploring the area for brunch or finding a neighborhood coffee spot, then just get a hotel. Many Airbnbs provide coffee, teas, even breakfast options, but don't expect one of those Belgian wafflers or an omelet chef to materialize in the kitchen just for you. If the success of your trip is dependent on such expectations, get a hotel.
- ...don't want extra space as a lone traveler (or extra space makes you nervous). Unless you book just a room on Airbnb, you will typically get an apartment or house for your stay. Some guests who travel alone find having more space to be off-putting, or they like the sense of security that a hotel of guests offers. If having more space than necessary bothers you, best to keep to the classic hotel layout.
- ...rely on hotel toiletries. Most Airbnbs have plentiful toiletries, but if you need the reliability of tiny bottles of soap and lotion (and look forward to swiping them), the hotel is your best choice.
- ...need modern facilities with no idiosyncracies. Airbnbs are homes, after all, so there might be a key with a certain trick to it, or a breaker might flip, or maybe hot and cold faucets are reversed (all true in one of my buildings!) If those issues really get to you, or if you are frustrated by some oddity, then don't bother. Be comfortable in the hotel where you won't be a headache to your host.
- ...don't enjoy traveling. I will be honest here. Even though I host on Airbnb, I often look forward to the predictability of a hotel when I'm really tired and in a strange place. If you don't want your lodging to feature prominently in your travel experience, get a hotel.
- ...want to pay more. 'Nuff said.
If you don't qualify for the above, then hurray! You've made next step.
You should choose an Airbnb if you...
- ...enjoy other people. You may get to meet your host, which can be a plus or minus, based on the booking situation. You might also encounter other guests as neighbors, so enjoying meeting others is key for a fun and comfortable Airbnb stay.
- ...love other homes or houses. Are you one of those people who loves home tours or real estate open houses? Do you like staying with friends or seeing where they live? Do you enjoy home decor or getting ideas about your own space? Then Airbnb is a great fit. I got so many ideas just from staying in other Airbnbs... and even just staying in friends' houses! I love to see the personality of others' homes. If you do, too, then definitely explore an Airbnb stay.
- ...don't mind the idiosyncracies of houses that aren't yours. As I mentioned above, we all know that our living spaces have quirks -- pull the doorknob a certain way to make it click, turn the shower on by a near-hidden lever, jiggle the dresser drawer just so to make it slide shut. We have to adapt sometimes. Hosts do appreciate a bit of feedback on stuff that isn't perfect. However, if you can't cope with a door that sticks a bit in hot weather, for example, then maybe the slide key card at the hotel is the best pick for you.
- ...are adaptable. Do you adjust fairly well to being "out of your element"? Does spending a bit of time searching for a cutting board not throw you off? Does using a certain brand of toilet paper for a few days' stay not disturb your sense of comfort? Then an Airbnb is a good choice.
- ...communicate well. If you stay at an Airbnb, contact your host with your questions or needs. Let them help you. If you don't communicate well, find yourself dissatisfied with something, and then rant in the review.....well, that was your fault for not asking. Good communicators always have better stays and relationships with hosts.
- ...pay attention to details. Read your chosen listing carefully and completely. We find that guests have questions or problems about things that are often answered clearly online or in our welcome message. Be sure you know check-in/check-out times, key information, how or where to park, etc. Not all Airbnbs are the same. That's what hotels are for.
- ...are respectful to others' property and homes. Sure, you wouldn't leave a drink on a table without a coaster on your own table, but, oh well, it doesn't matter at your Airbnb, right? Totally wrong. In fact, just like in a hotel, it might land you with extra fees if you damage or break items at your Airbnb. I once had guest ruin a coffee table by leaving a spilled drink that got trapped under the coaster (yes, riddle me that). Your Airbnb is someone's home and property, and if you can't treat it as your own, then you should just go to the hotel with its slick varnished tables that repel liquids.
Now, if an Airbnb sounds good to you, then may I suggest Urban Roost? :)
You will enjoy Urban Roost if you...
- ...don't mind some 1920s style. Our buildings were built in 1925, so yes, they are old. We have some creaky floors and some thin walls, but we also have stylish stained glass, arched walls between the living and dining rooms, and lovely trim and baseboards. One of our units -- the Sparrow Suite -- even has some original lighting fixtures!
- ...dig vintage. We shop and collect vintage as much as we can. Just take a look through our photos online, and you are bound to see some of our favorite finds on display in the units, especially in the kitchens.
- ...enjoy exploring your space. We put little touches everywhere just to add some "wow" factor when you least expect it. Piles of best-loved books, original works by artist friends, seasonal decor, warm throws and blankets, yoga mats.... we may not think of everything, but we try!
- ...want to be centrally-located in St Louis city. Most of our hotels are downtown or near the airport. Our South City listings will place you just about 10-15 minutes from any major attraction and neighborhood. Some are just walking distance to key areas like South Grand, Tower Grove Park, or the Botanical Gardens. We are also really close to major grocery stores and shopping.
- ...want to feel at home while you travel. Many of our guests report how happy they were to stay in a home, or a place that made them feel at home. That's exactly our goal!
So come stay with us if Urban Roost on Airbnb is for you. We are excited to help you live like a local.
